Get ready for a thrilling twist on a cult classic—The Lost Boys is sinking its fangs into Broadway! But here’s where it gets controversial: Can a beloved 1987 vampire film truly be transformed into a stage musical without losing its edgy, dark charm? Announced in late 2023, Patrick Wilson—known for his roles in The Conjuring and Insidious franchises—is producing this bold adaptation of Joel Schumacher’s iconic horror flick. And this is the part most people miss: it’s not just a musical; it’s a full-blown theatrical reimagining with a star-studded cast and creative team that’s raising eyebrows and expectations alike.
Previews for The Lost Boys: A New Musical kick off on Friday, March 27, 2026, at the Palace Theatre on Broadway. The cast includes Caissie Levy (Ragtime) as Lucy Emerson, LJ Benet tackling Michael Emerson’s role, and Ali Louis Bourzgui stepping into the shoes of the charismatic vampire David. Benjamin Pajak, Maria Wirries, and Paul Alexander Nolan round out the ensemble, bringing fresh energy to characters fans have adored for decades. But the real question is: Will this musical capture the film’s rebellious spirit, or will it fall flat under the weight of its own ambition?
Behind the scenes, the creative team is a powerhouse. It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia writer David Hornsby penned the book alongside Broadway’s Chris Hoch, while pop-rock band The Rescues composed the score. Parade director Michael Arden helms the production, and Ethan Popp (Tina: The Tina Turner Musical) serves as Music Supervisor. With scenic design by Dane Laffrey and costumes by Ryan Park, this musical promises to be a visual feast. But will it satisfy die-hard fans of the original film?
The story remains true to the 1987 classic: teenage brothers Michael and Sam move to a small California town, where Michael falls for Star, a woman entangled with a vampire gang. Sam, alongside his geeky friends Edward and Alan, must save Michael and Star from the undead. It’s a tale of love, rebellion, and survival—but with songs. And this is where opinions will clash: Can a musical truly do justice to the film’s gritty, dark humor and heart-pounding suspense?
As the production gears up for its Broadway debut, the buzz is undeniable. But here’s the burning question: Will The Lost Boys: A New Musical become a theatrical triumph or a well-intentioned misstep? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—are you excited to see this horror classic reimagined, or do you think some stories are better left untouched? One thing’s for sure: this musical is bound to spark debate long after the curtain falls.
